Looking for the Best SEO Services in New York?
Eliza Forgacs
Finding a trustworthy agency which delivers on its promises, and shows results instead of excuses—can be hard, especially in the crowded market of the U.S. Here we gathered the industry leader SEO agencies from New York City, who all have top-level expertise in various fields of SEO, with positive customer reviews and showcases of successful projects.
How to Choose the Best SEO Agency in New York City?
Before we dive deep into the list of best SEO services you can find in NYC, you should know how to make your final choice when hiring an agency. Before selecting, consider:
- There are several types of SEO. Local, e-commerce, SaaS, enterprise-level… etc. Ensure the agency specializes in the type of SEO you need.
- Take your time and investigate each agencies’ experience in your industry. A legitimate track record can easily be proven with a Google search.
- When in discussion, inquire about reporting and strategies. Choose agencies that provide transparency.
- Different needs require different solutions. Opt for agencies that offer tailored SEO strategies to meet your specific business goals.
Top SEO Agencies in New York City
Without further ado, here is Ranking Raccoon’s Top 10 list of SEO companies in New York. Find key information, real reviews and some industry secrets here and there.
1. Mettano
Mettano offers website design and digital marketing services, but mainly specializes in local SEO services. They make some strong promises, such as ranking number 1 on Google. We all know that’s not so easy to achieve… But they have a proven track record, great customer reviews and offer tailored, local SEO strategies.
SEO services they offer:
- Keyword Research & Competitor Analysis
- Algorithm Impact Analysis & Resolution
- Link Building & Audit (Off-Page SEO)
- Site Architecture Analysis
- Google Search Console & Google Analytics
- On-Page SEO Optimization
- Content Analysis & Creation
- 404 Error Identification, Resolution & Redirects
- Page Speed Improvement
Real customer review:
“I can’t recommend this digital marketing company enough! From day one, they were professional, responsive, and truly invested in helping my business grow. They took the time to understand my goals and built a strategy that delivered real results.”
Read all the reviews here.
2. Mimvi
Mimvi is one of the leading SEO agencies in New York City and Long Island. They also offer digital marketing campaigns and have over a decade of experience. Their SEO solutions promise exceptional results, but looking through their reviews—with a 100% satisfaction rate, I believe they can deliver. They are familiar with e-commerce SEO, so if that’s your niche, go for it!
SEO services from Mimvi:
- SEO Audit & Strategy Consultation
- Keyword Research & Optimization
- SEO Content Creation
- Technical SEO
- Authoritative Link Building
- Local SEO Services
- Website & Speed Optimization
- E-Commerce SEO
- SEO Reporting & Tracking
Real customer review:
“Mimvi is by far, the top, most helpful, marketing company and team out there. I'm thoroughly impressed and satisfied with what's coming into my pipeline.”
Read more reviews here.
3. Digital Drew SEM
Digital Drew offers a wide range of digital solutions for businesses of all sizes—starting with Google and social media ads, even email marketing and website development. They are experts in leveraging the power of SEO. They have a success rate of 96%, 610 completed SEO projects and 250 happy clients.
They have a complex SEO process, which covers the whole SEO journey in the following steps:
- Everything starts with a SEO questionnaire to help create a tailored strategy
- Identifying and using the right keywords
- Website content optimization
- High-quality link building
- Tracking and analyzing performance
Real customer review:
“We have been working with Digital Drew SEM for just over a month and a half, and the results have been outstanding. Our sales have already doubled. What sets Drew apart is that you actually work directly with him, not just a coworker or junior account manager like most other advertising companies. His knowledge of Google, Meta, and SEO is exceptional, and with his guidance, expertise, and experience, we feel confident our business will continue to grow and reach new heights.”
Read more opinions here.
4. BlueHat Marketing
BlueHat Marketing is known for its data-backed approach. Originally operating in Canada, now they offer services worldwide (1,150 happy clients globally). They have worked with hundreds of clients to boost online visibility, traffic, and conversions. Their methods combine SEO, content marketing, and analytics to achieve sustainable long-term results.
Their SEO services:
- Local SEO
- Enterprise SEO
- International SEO
- National SEO
- Hybrid SEO
- SEO consulting
- SEO audit
Real client review:
“BlueHat Marketing did a really awesome job with my website! My traffic and search engine rankings have climbed significantly since I started working with them. They're a responsive team who provide clear reports and really know how to get results. Highly recommend!”
Learn more honest reviews here.
5. Silverback Strategies
Silverback Strategies is a performance-driven marketing agency, known for transparent reporting and measurable impact. Their team focuses on aligning marketing goals with business outcomes, rather than vanity metrics. They mainly serve industries such as finance, healthcare, higher education, and legal services.
Complex SEO solutions they offer:
- Search Engine Optimization
- Content marketing
- Social Search Optimization
- Technical SEO
Honest customer feedback:
“Since we started with Silverback, we’ve seen phenomenal growth. I’ve worked with a lot of agencies over my 21 years in digital, and Silverback’s fantastic. I’m happy with everything that they’ve done so far.”
You can find the reviews here.
6. Intero Digital
Intero Digital is one of the largest integrated digital marketing agencies in the U.S., offering comprehensive SEO solutions across multiple industries. Their data-driven approach sounds convincing and they keep a keen eye on industry changes. They seem like a fast-paced company that can deliver results (and their reviews support my impressions). Intero can deliver exceptional growth for B2B and B2C clients alike.
Main SEO services Intero Digital offers:
- E-commerce SEO
- Local SEO
- National SEO
- Link Building
- SEO content writing
- Generative Engine Optimization (GEO)
Real client review:
“We work with Intero on SEO, general website maintenance and optimization, and website redesign and platform migration. After many years of success with SEO and general website work, when it came time to redesign our site and move to a different hosting platform, they were the obvious choice for the project. These folks are pros!”
Interested? Read more here.
7. SeoProfy
SeoProfy is known for its deep technical SEO expertise and ROI-focused approach. They’ve helped hundreds of businesses grow organic traffic through advanced analytics and tailored growth strategies. Their transparent, research-heavy process appeals to companies seeking measurable, lasting SEO performance.
What does SeoProfy offer?
- Enterprise SEO
- International SEO
- Local SEO
- SEO audit
- SEO consulting
- SEO management
- Google penalty recovery
- Link building
What do their clients say?
“Got a great result after 8 months of collaboration. My priority business search queries have finally ranked on the first page of Google.”
Read all of the reviews here.
8. SearchX
SearchX promises to deliver numbers. As an agency specialized in performance-driven organic growth, it has become a trusted SEO company for a huge clientele. They are experts not just in local SEO, but they mastered AI-based ranking analysis, helping businesses understand search intent better than ever before. Their agile, startup-style approach makes them a favorite among small to mid-sized companies.
They create a custom blend of SEO tactics for you, which can contain the following:
- Keyword research and strategy
- Content creation
- Content optimization
- Local SEO
- Technical SEO
- Link building and guest posting
- Analytics and reporting
An honest client review:
“They do an amazing job with SEO. Their strategies really help websites stand out, leading to noticeable increases in organic traffic and search engine rankings. The team is highly skilled, easy to communicate with, and always on top of the latest trends.”
Read all of the reviews here.
9. Firestarter SEO
Founded in Denver and expanding into the New York market, Firestarter SEO has been recognized for its transparent processes and tangible results. Their no-fluff approach focuses on real keyword movement and ROI, rather than vanity rankings. Their small but experienced team offers personalized support to each client.
They offer a proven framework which contains the following, customizable steps:
- Audit & discovery
- Technical SEO
- On-site optimization
- Link building
- Reporting
Real customer reviews:
“They more than doubled visits to our website. Increased conversion rates by more than 100% and grew our customer base by 25%.”
Read more feedback here.
10. 2POINT
2POINT is a creative SEO and web design agency combining branding with performance marketing. Based in San Diego with clients in New York, they blend visual identity with technical SEO to help businesses stand out in competitive markets. Their campaigns often include content design, animation, and conversion-focused UX strategies.
They have different tiers for various SEO projects which can contain:
- Audit & keyword selection
- Assembling a group of specialists
- Quarterly content plan
- Improving technical and on-page SEO
- Content creation and optimization
- Backlink strategy
Real client review about their new website creation:
“Working with 2POINT to develop my e-commerce site has been a game-changer for my business. From the outset, their team demonstrated a remarkable level of expertise, creativity, and commitment. They took the time to understand my vision and translated it into a beautiful, user-friendly website that exceeds my expectations.”
Read more reviews here.
The Best SEO Agency for Your Business
Choosing the right SEO agency in New York City is crucial for your online success. The agencies listed above have demonstrated expertise and success in various aspects of SEO. By considering your specific needs and goals, you can select an agency that aligns with your business objectives. Remember, SEO is a long-term investment, and partnering with the right agency can yield significant returns.
Also, you shouldn’t forget about one crucial part of SEO: link building. Yes, it is still important, still relevant, still hard to do. Without quality backlinks your website will stay invisible, even if your content is the best and was optimized to the right keywords. In today’s competitive field, on-page SEO is just not enough.
How to build links in the U.S. market in 2025?
Building links still stinks. But jokes aside, it really is one of the most draining parts of SEO. If you’re looking for an agency to build links for your business (and to escape the insufferable hours of prospecting and unsuccessful outreach tries), I’d suggest taking one last try yourself before outsourcing link building.
Facts about today’s link building landscape:
- The U.S. market has become one of the most competitive environments for link building.
- Depending on the industry, the average cold email reply rate is around 4-6%.
- 94% of online content never earns a single backlink, while only 2.2% of pages attract links from multiple sources.
- According to fresh reports, $508.95 is the average “fair price” for one high-quality backlink.
- The same survey points out that the average minimum monthly link building budget required in highly competitive niches is around $8,406.
What do these numbers show us?
- Generic mass emails mean nothing—they don’t stand a chance.
- Your content must provide value, otherwise it will go unnoticed.
- Link building has become quite expensive, especially in high-difficulty niches (like SaaS).
- A value-driven SEO outreach strategy is critical—make your backlinks count.
While the listed agencies can handle your on-page and technical SEO, there’s one area that even the best SEO company in New York struggles with—link building.
Give Ranking Raccoon a Try
At Ranking Raccoon, we understand that link building is one of the most challenging aspects of SEO. It's not just about acquiring links; it's about acquiring the right links that drive traffic and truly improve rankings. On Raccoon you can meet and connect with agencies, in-house marketers, business owners, and SEO professionals to exchange backlinks and guest post options in a safe environment.
Our platform helps find the backlink opportunities that help you move the needle. Every website in our community is manually reviewed and every user is authenticated through LinkedIn—which means we don’t allow spam or sketchy businesses into our platform. Here you don’t have to pay for links, actually paid links are forbidden. Although we a have $25 membership fee which guarantees you full access to our database (you can use Ranking Raccoon for free, but with some limitations).
If you want to give link building another try, but also enjoy a cheaper, faster, more successful way, give Ranking Raccoon a try!
Eliza Forgacs
Marketing Manager